Forum
Question About The Detroit '83 Shows
So I'm looking through the concert history section on here and at setlists on a few other sites for these shows (Nov 17 & 18) and I can't find You Shook Me All Night Long listed on any, and yet it's one of the tracks on Disc 2 (Deluxe Edition) of Backtracks, Live Rarities. Can anyone explain?? Thanks and sorry for all the questions lately!!
Yeah I had a question like that too. Because I always though You shook me all night long was from another show. Because Brians voice is different from the other songs played. So good question Hells Death! ;) Hope someone can answer it! :)
Good point BigJack. I had never noticed that before. It took me a minute but I totally can hear a difference
@ Hells I also listened to the track and noticed the difference in Brian's voice, so this may have been from a different show, who knows. Even official material that is released has mistakes, so probably a goof on the labels part on stating this was from the Detroit show. If you look at the setlist in the Concert History (1983 dates), you will notice some shows YSMANL wasplayed, other times they weren't. A good example is the 'Ohio Badlands' boot (11-11-83 Cincinnati show) where it was not played because the whole show was recorded and it is was not performed. But then a few days earlier at the 11-9-83 Rosemont Horizon (Chicago, IL) show it was. See where I am getting at? Hope this clears things up ;)
Get your point ShakedownIce! Thx :) But you think that Ysmanl is from another show and not from the detroit show right? Because I think this was the main question ;)
^ Correct, but just my take on it mainly because of the difference in sound (Brian's voice, crowd noice, etc.). Cheers!
Ok so it is... but is the information lost to us as to which show it did come from?? Any guesses?? The recording sounds like it is definitely from that era (hence the mix up possibly) or maybe it was like Nervous Shakedown from the 17, a pre-show rehearsal?? Who's gonna honestly know at this point, right?? Though that idea is a bit far-fetched I understand... :P
i think that the vocals in this recording are the same of the album version, just sped up.
if you listen to the version on the maxi-single, at the end/fade out, you can hear that For Those About To Rock starts. perhaps that could indicate its not from a rehearsal..
I've made a small audio clip with the live '83 version on the left channel and an edited studio version (to match the tempo difference) on the right channel. http://www.4shared.com/mp3/xCkKZLBe/shook_me_live_-_studio_comp.html sounds similar heh??
Well maybe..but no I don't think that you are right sry ;) Think it's a live version from the filck nof the switch tour. Don't know which concert but i'm sure about that ;)