Forum

Posted Apr 22, 2005 @ 5:49 pm by masterx449 - 929 views

i think my copies of the Irvine '86 and Melbourne '88 soundboard shows have the same copies of WMW, maybe others..i'm not sure yet. i listened to each about 5 times, and the same things are similar, same intro, same vocal messup by brian during the chorus. if someone could second that..that'd be great. -dan

Posted Apr 23, 2005 @ 11:29 pm by BigNate

i'll compare mine and post back on monday. Nate

Posted Apr 24, 2005 @ 8:14 am by bushman

who made who is the same as are some other songs but i have different set lists for both so something is screwed up

Posted Apr 24, 2005 @ 8:50 am by masterx449

thanks nate yeah bushman dirty deeds is also the same lol..i went into wavelab and played them at the same time.. thats really weird:-/ -dan

Posted May 5, 2005 @ 11:03 am by BigNate

I finally checked my copies. Who Made Who is the same for both shows that I have. I have 3 copies of the Melbourne show (all probably the same source, but I'm too stubborn to delete them) and 2 of those 3 have the same Who Made Who as the Irvine show from '86. The third is missing Who Made Who so I'd lean toward saying that the Irvine show has the correct track. I'll talk it over with a few other people and post back eventually. Damn good find masterx. Would have never noticed that. Nate

Posted May 10, 2005 @ 7:30 pm by LiveWire14

I had noticed the same thing too, except for WMW is the only track I have from the Irvine show, so I thought the person I got it from had the wrong info

Posted May 20, 2005 @ 10:38 am by Jack Death

Dont mean to but in! But the Irvine Meadows show in Laguna Hills California is the correct Track. Why do I know this? because My Best friend is the one that recorded it!

Posted Jul 14, 2005 @ 11:55 am by spaterrock

Sometimes when someone is mastering a bootleg and a track is messed up, they will put a track from another show of the same(or nearly the same) quality in an attempt to make it seem like a comeplete show without bad tracks. I have a few recordings where this is done. I don't necissarily agree with that kind of thinking, but its clear that its done from time to time. Often, when you get a bootleg from a company such as Jack records, its clear that they really don't know a lot about what they are dealing with and simply go for the quickest solution, without so much as checking the facts or even spelling.

Posted Jul 14, 2005 @ 2:22 pm by davidceltic

this happens a lot! laguna hills is all available apart from whole lotta rosie which comes from a different show melbourne 88 only 12 tracks are available and other tracks have been taken from 3 other soundboard shows to complete it! hail hail..................davidceltic